Why does \sqrt{2} \ne \frac{7}{5}? Well, if it did, we could draw a square of side 5 and diagonal 7 Not in proportion! Then, by removing 5 from the diagonal we could create a second square of side 2 and diagonal 3, which would mean \sqrt{2} = \frac{3}{2}, which is a different fraction to \frac{7}{5}. Actually, we can easily generalize this argument to show that if \sqrt{2} = \frac{a}{b} for some whole numbers a and b, then \sqrt{2} = \frac{c}{d} for some smaller whole numbers c \lt a and d \lt b. Repeating this argument over and over leads us to the conclusion that \sqrt{2} is a whole number itself! This is clearly incorrect and leads us to the conclusion that we can't in fact write \sqrt{2} as a fraction. This is not a particularly modern way to prove the existence of irrational (non-fraction) numbers, but it is - supposedly - how the ancient Greeks originally did it! Unfortunately the person who discovered this fact, Hippasu...